Recasted actors are actors and actresses who have played two or more different characters on the same tv show; in this case Murdoch Mysteries.
The actor's first role is listed first, then their second role. They are listed by first episode appearance.
List of Recasted actors
- Patrick Garrow as Allen Fawkes in Power / Helmut Lindemann in Murdoch Au Naturel
- David Huband as Daniel Pratt in Power / Mayor Clarkson in Murdoch and the Cloud of Doom, Blast of Silence, High Voltage and A Merry Murdoch Christmas
- Alex Poch-Goldin as Hubert Winston in Elementary, My Dear Murdoch / Robert Grimsby in Murdoch On The Corner
- Michael Rhoades as John Delaney in Let Loose the Dogs / Oscar Kingsley in A Study in Sherlock
- David Christo as David Martin in Body Double / Warren Padgett in Tour de Murdoch
- James Downing as Coach Kane in Still Waters / Crown Attorney Atkinson in On the Waterfront Part 2
- Duncan McLeod as Roderick Grimesby in Belly Speaker / Keating's men in Hangman
- Richard Waugh as Peter Watt in Child's Play / Mason Alexander in Loch Ness Murdoch
- Robert Clarke as Andrew Nesbitt in Bad Medicine / Howard Briggs in The Ghost of Queen's Park
- Stephen Bogaert as Richard Binney in Bad Medicine / Dr. Clark in Murdochophobia
- Chad Connell as Prince Alfred in The Prince and the Rebel / Owen Mathers in Murdoch Ahoy
- Geordie Johnson as Barkeley Blake in Dinosaur Fever / Crown Prosecutor Daniels in Weekend at Murdoch's
- Anthony Lemke as Henry Bixby in Shades of Grey / Father Clements in Glory Days
- David Storch as Drygus Alger in Future Imperfect / Thomas Edison in The Filmed Adventures of Detective William Murdoch and High Voltage
- Chantal Craig as Teacher in Love and Human Remains / Cecily Welsh in Blast of Silence
- Emma Campbell as Mrs Burnside in All Tattered and Torn / Rose in Friday the 13th, 1901 and The Incurables
- Michael Spencer Davis as Dr Henderson in Kommando / Bradley Fowler in Blast of Silence
- Melanie Leishman as Nancy Booth in Downstairs, Upstairs / Sarah Harrison in The Spy Who Came Up to the Cold
- Wayne Ward as Jason Lawrence in Dial M for Murdoch / Guard Potter in Victoria Cross
- Christian Distefano as Young Boy in Stroll on the Wild Side (Part 2) / Ben McQueen in Return of Sherlock Holmes
- Alex Paxton-Beesley as Lillie Dunn in Shades of Grey / Winnifred “Freddie” Pink in Summer of '75, Wild Child, A Study in Pink and Hades Hath No Fury
- Catherine Fitch as Flora Rookwood in Child's Play / recast as the bank teller Catherine Tweedale in Raised On Robbery.
- Laurie Murdoch as Martin Hammerton in I, Murdoch / Alvin Nash in Mr. Murdoch's Neighbourhood.
- Stewart Arnott as Dr. Lawrence Abbott in Buffalo Shuffle / William Osler in Dr. Osler Regrets.
- Kristopher Turner as Sam Fineman in Let Us Ask the Maiden / Jack Borden in Dr. Osler Regrets.
- Benjamin Blais as Billy Slater in Downstairs, Upstairs / Archie Doyle in Dr. Osler Regrets.
- Sarah Orenstein as Clara Pollack in The Glass Ceiling / Catherine Doyle in Dr. Osler Regrets.
- Cyrus Lane as Roger Newsome in The Death of Dr. Ogden / Rupert Newsome in Biffers and Blockers.
- Harry Judge as Matthew Larson in Kommando / Father McGray in Mary Wept.
- Matt Baram as Edward Simms in the Houdini Whodunit / Roderick Rhodes in Crabtree à la Carte.
- Daniel Kash as Arthur Frumm in All Tattered and Torn / Randall Gordon in Crabtree à la Carte.
- Stephanie Belding as Jean Palmerson in Murdoch On The Corner / Kate Sullivan in Murdoch Without Borders.