Mr. Carmichael is the father of Isabel and Arthur Carmichael introduced in Season 12 of Murdoch Mysteries, portrayed by Ben Carlson.
Appearances and Mentions
Darkness Before the Dawn Part 2
- At first, Detective Murdoch and team discover that Crown lawyer Mr. Carmichael's son Arthur Carmichael had previous misdemeanors dropped by the Crown leading them to believe that his father has been covering for him. When they question Arthur, they find out he has an alibi: purchasing an Apollo car in Chicago during the murder, but failed to mention it to protect his father.
- Before his arrest, Mr. Carmichael' has a written confession ready stating that he killed them all, then shoots himself.
- Afterwards Detective Watts is reading the confession only to find inconsistencies and once the bullet is found, the team realizes both Carmichaels were covering for Isabel Carmichael, who used John's gun to murder Lucille and Grant Sutton.