Murdoch Mysteries Wiki
Spoiler warning!
This article contains plot details or information about an upcoming episode/season which has not been aired world-wide yet. Don't believe everything you read, content is subject to change at any time.

"Everything is Broken Part 2” is the eleventh episode of fourteenth season of the Murdoch Mysteries and the two hundred fifteenth episode of the series (not including the three stand-alone holiday specials). It first aired March 15, 2021.


Reeling from a personal revelation, Murdoch seeks to avenge the murder of Anna Fulford.

Murdoch realizes that the boy who shot at the Blackhand crime boss is his son. Julia is stunned but eager to accept the boy out of love for William.

Elsewhere, love takes a beating as Crabtree's proposal to Effie is dashed, Watts braces for Jack's marriage, and Higgins and Ruth remain separated. Family is the one thing holding Brackenreid together as he resists pressure to resign from his job.

Character Revelations

  • Henry and Ruth welcomed a daughter, with a little help from Margaret and Julia...
  • In a rare moment, Julia confides in Margaret as she copes with William having another love in his life – the son that they are unable to have together; The two very different women share a similar familial situation.
  • Amelia and Dorothy are twin sisters: Dorothy is the truly evil one, whereas Amelia just wants to marry George because she loves him and Dorothy is trying to facilitate that.


  • Julia recalls (via flashbacks) her joy and sorrow trying to have a child with William...
  • Station House No. 4 stands by their Inspector...

Historical References

  • This episode takes place in Toronto 1908 – Edward VII (Albert Edward;1841-1910) is King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and of the British Dominions beyond the Seas.


  • Showrunner Peter Mitchell states, "There is an awareness of what the fans are thinking and if some fan is actually thinking exactly what we were going to do, we change it if we have time. We still write for that four-quadrant group of fans who want the mystery, the ones who want the romance, the ones who want science and the ones who want Victoriana … or Edwardiana now." He reveals, "I always knew, from the minute I saw Sarah Swire appear on the show as Amelia Ernst that she was going to be in the finale...I knew that we would have to circle back around on Bobby, and the twisted little relationship between Violet and Arthur we were pretty sure on very early. The Murdoch storyline may have come last. Once we realized we were going to do that, there was no way the physical Anna (Lisa Faulkner) would be in Canada (not to mention COVID restrictions), so we went with the memory of Anna. And, as you can tell, that story is far from resolved."
  • On Hélène Joy's performance, director Peter Mitchell adds, "Hélène dialed into that stuff and, as an actress, is aware of overplaying that stuff and doesn’t. She kills in the small moments and I really didn’t have to talk too much to her about it. You have to have guts to portray insecurities and she did a really good job."
  • Anna Fulford has yet to reappear and is only mentioned thus far.

Notable Quotes

Julia to Margaret: "No, they are. He had a child with another woman before we married. Exactly the same."
William to Julia: "Julia, I love you just as I always have."


  • While “between you and I" was said in the 19th century by most well-educated Edwardians and some writers would have been taught it (even into the late 20th), this is not the first time this grammar error has been pointed out by Murdochians – when to say I and when to say me: It’s between you and me, about him and me, with her and me, and from you and me.


Main Cast

Yannick Bisson as Detective William Murdoch
Hélène Joy as Dr. Julia Ogden
Thomas Craig as Inspector Thomas Brackenreid
Jonny Harris as Constable George Crabtree

Recurring Cast

Daniel Maslany as Detective Watts
Lachlan Murdoch as Constable Henry Higgins
Siobhan Murphy as Ruth Higgins-Newsome
Arwen Humphreys as Margaret Brackenreid
Clare McConnell as Effie Newsome
Shailene Garnett as Nomi Johnston
Shanice Banton as Violet Hart
James Graham as Arthur Carmichael
Clare McConnell as Effie Newsome
Sarah Swire as Dorothy Ernst
Jesse Lavercombe as Jack Walker
Nathan Hoppe as Constable McNabb
Ric Reid as Chief Constable
Nicholas Spencer as Jake Matthews
Brendan Wall as Inspector Decker

Guest Cast

Etienne Kellici as Harry
Brendan Murray as Frank Rhodes
Austin Di Iulio as Joe Falcone
Debra Hale as Helga
Franco Lo Presti as Tony

Non-Credited Cast


Murdoch Mysteries Season 14
Murdoch and the Tramp Rough and TumbleCode M for MurdochShock Value
Murder Checks InThe Ministry of VirtueMurdoch Escape RoomThe Dominion of New South MimicoThe .38 Murdoch SpecialEverything is Broken Part 1Everything is Broken Part 2

Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 5Season 6Season 7Season 8Season 9Season 10Season 11Season 12Season 13Season 14