Arthur Carmichael
1217 Arthur Carmichael.png
Actor James Graham
Seen Darkness Before the Dawn Part 1
Gender Male
Status Living
Relationships Isabel Carmichael, sister
Mr. Carmichael, father
John Brackenreid, sister's suitor

Arthur Carmichael is the brother of Isabel Carmichael and the son of a Chief Crown Attorney, introduced in Season 12 of Murdoch Mysteries, portrayed by James Graham.

Appearances and Mentions

Darkness Before the Dawn Part 1

  • Arthur Carmichael is a person of interest in the death of Lucille Palmer. When first questioned by Murdoch and McWorthy, he confesses to having an affair with Lucille but denies getting her in a family way or killing her.
  • Carmichael's callous attitude prompts Murdoch to warn him, "Wipe that smirk off your face, or I will do it for you."

Darkness Before the Dawn Part 2

  • Arthur Carmichael has an alibi for the shooting of Grant Sutton, but Murdoch and Crabtree don't yet know his whereabouts for the shooting of Lucille Palmer; With four days unaccounted for, Mr. Carmichael is the most compelling suspect.
  • After transcribing the entries from the subpoenaed logbook for Crabtree, Effie Newsome has discoversed that Arthur Carmichael was arrested for a variety of crimes and gives George the file folder.



Murdoch Mysteries Season 12
Murdoch Mystery MansionOperation: MurderMy Big Fat Mimico WeddingMurdoch Without Borders
The Spy Who Loved MurdochSir. Sir? Sir!!!Brother's KeeperDrowning in MoneySecrets and Lies
Pirates of the Great LakesAnnabella CinderellaSix of the BestMurdoch and the Undetectable Man
Sins of the FatherOne Minute to MurderManual for MurderDarkness Before the Dawn Part 1
Darkness Before the Dawn Part 2
Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 5Season 6Season 7Season 8Season 9Season 10Season 11Season 12
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.