|Seen||Darkness Before the Dawn Part 1|
|Relationships||Isabel Carmichael, sister|
Mr. Carmichael, father
John Brackenreid, sister's suitor
Appearances and Mentions
- Arthur Carmichael is a person of interest in the death of Lucille Palmer. When first questioned by Murdoch and McWorthy, he confesses to having an affair with Lucille but denies getting her in a family way or killing her.
- Carmichael's callous attitude prompts Murdoch to warn him, "Wipe that smirk off your face, or I will do it for you."
- Arthur Carmichael has an alibi for the shooting of Grant Sutton, but Murdoch and Crabtree don't yet know his whereabouts for the shooting of Lucille Palmer; With four days unaccounted for, Mr. Carmichael is the most compelling suspect.
- After transcribing the entries from the subpoenaed logbook for Crabtree, Effie Newsome has discoversed that Arthur Carmichael was arrested for a variety of crimes and gives George the file folder.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.